Uncle Bobby Johnson on Oakland Police Oversight and BART Accountability
Cephus "Uncle Bobby" Johnson, uncle of Oscar Grant, argues that lifting federal oversight of the Oakland Police Department was premature despite recent scandals. Speaking from his positions on California’s Peace Officer Standards Accountability Advisory Board and the BART Police Civilian Review Board, Johnson emphasizes that true accountability requires sustained community pressure, transparent investigations, and meaningful consequences for misconduct.
Cephus "Uncle Bobby" Johnson, the uncle of Oscar Grant and a long-time advocate for police accountability, has characterized the recent lifting of federal oversight over the Oakland Police Department (OPD) as premature. Speaking in an interview with the San Francisco Bay View, Johnson argued that ending nearly 24 years of federal supervision does not conclude the struggle for justice, particularly as new allegations of misconduct emerge within the department.
The decision to remove federal oversight came three months ago, following a period during which the department was monitored after being exposed for systemic human rights violations. The city of Oakland had previously paid out over $100 million in settlements after being sued regarding the actions of a group of officers known as the "Riders." Despite this history and the recent announcement by Oakland’s Black mayor, Barbra Lee, who posed with OPD leadership to mark the end of oversight, Johnson remains skeptical.
"In my view, lifting federal oversight was premature," Johnson said. "Twenty-three years under supervision should require clear evidence that accountability has become part of the department’s culture. Oakland deserves to see change in how officers treat residents, how complaints are investigated and whether misconduct brings meaningful consequences."
Johnson pointed to recent developments within the OPD as evidence that reforms may not yet be sustainable. He cited a scandal involving OPD pilots allegedly falsifying flight logs and obtaining certifications through false submissions. Federal prosecutors have alleged that two officers falsified records to obstruct an investigation, with both pleading not guilty. Johnson noted that while prosecutors must prove these allegations, they highlight serious concerns regarding dishonesty and public safety.
"The helicopter case deepens my concern," Johnson stated. "Federal prosecutors allege that two officers obtained pilot certifications through false submissions and that one falsified flight records to obstruct the investigation. Both officers pleaded not guilty, and prosecutors must prove those allegations. Still, allegations involving dishonesty and public safety demand independent scrutiny and public answers."
Johnson emphasized that for Black communities in Oakland, trust is earned through consistent action rather than administrative milestones. He called for robust independent civilian oversight with sufficient resources, access, and authority to hold officers and leadership accountable. "The public deserves transparency, consequences when wrongdoing is established and lasting protection of our civil rights," he said.
Beyond Oakland, Johnson serves on two significant state and regional bodies appointed to address police misconduct. In 2023, Governor Gavin Newsom appointed him to California’s Peace Officer Standards Accountability Advisory Board (POST). Created through Senate Bill 2, the nine-member board is designed to include a majority of members who are not current or former police officers, ensuring that communities affected by misconduct have a voice in decisions regarding policing authority.
The board’s primary function is to review serious-misconduct cases in public hearings and recommend whether an officer’s certification should be suspended or revoked. Decertification prevents officers found guilty of dishonesty, excessive force, sexual assault, or racial bias from simply moving to another department within the state. Johnson highlighted a recent success where the board recommended revoking the certifications of two officers in July 2026, a recommendation unanimously upheld by the POST Commission in September.
"Decertification means taking away an officer’s eligibility to serve as a peace officer in California," Johnson explained. "It provides a way to prevent an officer whose certification has been revoked from simply moving to another department and continuing to police another community."
Johnson also serves on the BART Police Civilian Review Board, appointed by the BART Board of Directors to the Public-at-Large seat. His term runs through June 30, 2028. This role holds personal significance for Johnson, given that his nephew, Oscar Grant, was murdered by a BART police officer on the Fruitvale platform in 2009, an event that sparked rebellions across downtown Oakland.
As a member of the review board, Johnson can vote on findings and disciplinary recommendations based on the Independent Police Auditor’s investigative reports. If the board agrees with the auditor’s findings, the police chief must implement the recommended discipline unless appealed. However, Johnson clarified that he cannot personally fire an officer or order an investigation; these powers are exercised collectively.
"Our role in discipline has real significance," Johnson said. "When the board agrees with the auditor’s findings and recommended discipline, the police chief must implement the recommended action unless it is appealed, subject to applicable due process requirements."
Johnson acknowledged that BART Police have made progress since Oscar Grant’s death, citing the implementation of body cameras, strengthened use-of-force policies, and the introduction of unarmed Transit Ambassadors and Crisis Intervention Specialists. These measures aim to provide more humane responses to individuals in mental health crises or experiencing homelessness.
"BART now has an Independent Police Auditor and a civilian review board," Johnson noted. "It requires body cameras, has strengthened its use-of-force policies and requires officers to attempt de-escalation and intervene when another officer uses excessive force. Those are meaningful safeguards when they are followed and enforced."
However, he warned that policies alone do not guarantee humane treatment during actual encounters. He stressed the need to examine whether officers listen to riders, provide time and space, and take complaints seriously. "For Black riders, young people, unhoused people and people experiencing mental health crises, dignity must be part of public safety," Johnson said.
Johnson also discussed his work outside California, where he helps connect families of victims of police violence through the Love Not Blood Campaign and the National Families United 4 Justice Network. He emphasized that the struggle for justice continues long after headlines fade, as families navigate grief while seeking records, legal support, and transparency.
"When police kill someone you love, the struggle continues long after the headlines disappear," Johnson said. "Families are grieving while trying to get records, understand investigations, find legal support and challenge narratives that can strip their loved one of their humanity."
He urged impacted families to recognize they do not have to face these challenges alone and that their experiences must inform solutions regarding investigations, oversight, and legislation. "We have knowledge that comes from living through the consequences of police violence," he said. "That experience belongs in discussions about investigations, oversight, legislation and public safety."
Johnson concluded by reiterating that accountability requires sustained work beyond the passage of laws. "A law opens the door; we have to keep pushing to make sure it delivers meaningful protection for the people," he said. He invited community members, impacted families, and advocates to contact him via email at [email protected], by phone at 510-706-7558, or through the Love Not Blood Campaign website.
The history of police accountability in Oakland is marked by significant events, including the exposure of the "Riders" unit in 2003 and the 2009 murder of Oscar Grant. In 2015, the city faced another scandal involving a teenage victim known as "Celeste Guap," who was trafficked by approximately a dozen Bay Area law enforcement agencies. That scandal led to the suicide of OPD officer Brendan O’Brien.
Johnson, who has remained on the front lines since his nephew’s death, views his current appointments not as a conclusion to the struggle, but as additional platforms to carry the demands of impacted families. "My contribution is bringing the experience of impacted families into that process," he said. "As Oscar Grant’s uncle, and through my work with families who have lost loved ones to police violence, I understand that behind every case file are people whose lives have been changed forever."
He stressed the importance of distinguishing between an investigation, a recommendation, and a final decision, noting that delays in these processes can be painful for waiting families. "We have a responsibility to be thorough and fair while remembering that delays affect real people," Johnson said.
Community participation remains central to his approach. "What has become clearest to me is that community participation must continue after a law is signed," he said. "We need people watching the hearings, asking questions and holding institutions accountable for their promises. My appointment gives me a seat at the table, and I take seriously the responsibility to bring the concerns of families and our communities to that table."
Johnson’s work underscores the ongoing tension between administrative reforms and the lived realities of those affected by police violence. While he acknowledges structural improvements in BART policing and the potential of state-level decertification powers, he maintains that trust must be continuously earned through transparency and consequences.
"For me, this appointment is a responsibility to the people who ride BART, to impacted families and to Oscar’s memory," Johnson said. "Every person deserves to reach their destination safely and be treated with dignity. Oscar should have made it home. I want every family using BART to have that assurance for their loved ones."
As Oakland moves forward without federal oversight, Johnson’s message is clear: the mechanisms for accountability exist, but their effectiveness depends on persistent community vigilance and the refusal to let standards slip in the absence of external monitoring.
P.F. da Conceiçao--JDB